Skip to main content

Presidents for the Fourth Johnson/Jackson

Andrew Jackson's stock is falling.  New Deal historians loved Jackson, which makes sense in the same way that it makes sense that they loved Woodrow Wilson.  As the Democratic Party moved away from its traditional defense of bigotry, however, loving Wilson and Jackson has become far more problematic for newer generations of historians.  Jackson used to be a great president, finishing comfortably in the top ten in these sorts of surveys; Siena College now has him in the next tier down, at #14, which is consistent with where others have placed him recently.  In Siena's categories, Jackson scores very high on Leadership (#5), Party Leadership (#2), and Executive Ability (#6); he's at the low end on Ability to Compromise (#38), the economy (#28), and low on Integrity and Intelligence (#23, on each). 

Lyndon Johnson has settled in more or less in the same area.  He's 16th in Siena's survey;.in the fourteen such surveys in wikipedia's entry, he's as high as 10th and as low as 18th.  Within the rankings, however, Johnson is like Jackson, with plenty of extremes.  Siena has him the very best at Relationship with Congress, and third at Party Leadership.  He's 5th in Domestic Accomplishments.  On the other hand...he's dead last in Foreign Policy Accomplishments, 37th in "Avoid Crucial Mistakes," 34th in Integrity. 

Let's see...first of all, on LBJ, I think the party leadership score is way too high; they don't (at least in their release) define what "Relationship with Congress"  means but it deteriorated pretty badly by the end, so I'm not sure that I'd put it in the top ten -- although he obviously had as much legislative success as any other president.  Again, it's how you define the terms, and how you count things.

Which is sort of my overall point in this post.  Granted, this is just a parlor game to begin with, but even as a parlor game it basically breaks down when you try to deal with these two presidents.  How do you average out Civil Rights, Voting Rights, Immigration...and Vietnam?  How do you average out the achievement of, well, Jacksonian democracy, with all that that implies, positive and negative?  Yes, Siena includes a category for "integrity," but there's no category for "Actions of a Moral Monster" -- and if there were, how would you weigh it? 

So I can't say that either Jackson or Johnson is overrated, or underrated...they just don't work in the Rating the Presidents Game, as far as I can tell.

Facebook

Facebook Recommendations

Followers


Web Designing In Karachi



Haroof.com


Politics blogs

My Zimbio

Email Subscribe

Enter your email address:

Watch online Live TV

Popular posts from this blog

Awaz Public Ki {Elections in Pakistan}

Q: As all the major parties are taking part in the elections, what future scenario do you foresee? Explain: The general elections are going to be held on January 8, 2008. All major political parties except two or three are participating in the elections. Among the major parties, contesting the elections, are Pakistan Muslim League (Q), Pakistan Muslim League (N), Pakistan People’s Party, Jamiat Ulma-e-Islam (F), Muttehadda Qaumi Movement, Pakistan Muslim League (Functional). As all the major parties are taking part in the elections, what future scenario do you foresee? Awaz Public Ki the elections will lead to a confused scenario if the establishment tried to manipulate the polls as it did in the past elections.they must avoid to engineer the elections, which will prove disasterous for the country. tanveer hussaini [Karachi]Posted on 26, Dec 2007 --> As far as future of polls.. the political system has been set on flames unfortunately.. I would like to say that for any successful n...

Microsoft SQL Server is the best among Microsoft’s Products

Microsoft has come up with Microsoft SQL server to cater to the needs of the computer operators, who want to provide advanced facilities on the other computers among networking process. The Microsoft SQL Server 2005 Express Edition is a newly developed product that is easy-to-use, lightweight, and enables the person to work more efficiently than before. The new SQL Server Express Edition with advanced facilities is perfect for use as a backend to a small, multi-user application that requires more superior features like Web reporting or full-text search. This Microsoft sql server standard express edition includes influential features as in SQL Server Management Studio Express that is capable of managing a database very easily. Along with this, it also creates and deploys database code such as stored procedures, user-defined types, functions, and user-defined aggregates from directly within the Visual Studio development environment. All these features tend to help you in enjoying your ...

Matric General Group Result SECONDARY SCHOOL CERTIFICATE (S. S. C.) PART - II CLASS - X - 2010 (www.apnieyesp.com )

PASSED THE SECONDARY SCHOOL CERTIFICATE (S. S. C.) PART - II CLASS - X) ANNUAL EXAMINATION, 2010. ERRORS AND OMISSIONS EXCEPTED, CANDIDATES BEARING THE FOLLOWING ROLL NUMBERS ARE DECLARED TO HAVE PASSED THE SECONDARY SCHOOL CERTIFICATE (S. S. C.) PART - II CLASS - X) ANNUAL EXAMINATION, 2010. ------------------------------------------------- GENERAL GROUP (REG&PVT) --- GRADE..'A-ONE' ---- ----------------------- ( CANDIDATES SECURING TOTAL MARKS 680 AND ABOVE) MARKS SECURED BY THE CANDIDATES OUT OF TOTAL MARKS OF 850 ARE MENTIONED AGAINST EACH ROLL NUMBER IN BRACKET --------------------------------------------------- 601086 (689) XXX (XXX) XXX (XXX) XXX (XXX) XXX (XXX) XXX (XXX) 601327 (681) 363 (684) 364 (719) 407 (685) 664 (682) 788 (687) 601836 (692) 882 (683) XXX (XXX) XXX (XXX) XXX (XXX) XXX (XXX) 602315 (723) 316 (715) 320 (712) 321 (739) 325 (686) 326 (702) 602327 (683) 329 (70...

Labels

Show more